Creepy

Truth Behind The Story Of Carmen Winstead – She Was Pushed!

The ghost of a teen named Carmen Winstead strikes down those who don't share or repost her story online.

In October 2006, a disturbing story about a teenage girl named Carmen Winstead, also known as Jessica Smith, circulated online and through emails. The story claimed that Carmen was pushed down a sewer by five of her female classmates at school and left to die. It was said that she was now seeking revenge for her death.

Advertisement

The Story Of Carmen Winstead Starts Here

As a young girl prepared to take a shower in her bathroom at home, she heard a strange, faint gurgling noise. Despite feeling that something was off about the noise, she dismissed it as an issue with the plumbing.

As she stepped into the shower and turned on the water, the strange sound grew louder and seemed to be coming from the drain. It was a laughing, mocking chuckle that could be heard clearly over the running water. The girl suspected that her mind was playing tricks on her.

Advertisement

However, the girl quickly remembered a tragic event that had occurred seven months prior, in which she had played a role. It had involved a black lie.

She called out to her mom, shouting, "Mom, there's a strange sound of laughter coming from the water pipe!" However, her mom only gave her a strange look and suggested that she forget about it and go to bed. The girl followed this advice, not realizing that her end was near.

Advertisement

That night, the mother heard a series of crusty noises and a loud bang coming from her daughter's room. She got out of bed to check on her daughter and found that the bed was empty. She searched the entire house, including the bathroom and basement, but was unable to find her daughter. She was shocked to discover that her daughter was gone.

The police were called in and conducted an investigation. It did not take long for them to find the girl, and they discovered something suspicious in a nearby sewer where the cap was partially opened.

Advertisement
Advertisement

As they shone their torches into the opening, they saw the missing girl, with her head turned towards them and her neck twisted in an unnatural way. Her face was stripped of flesh.

Four other girls would meet the same fate, as Carmen Winstead had returned for her revenge.

Who Is Carmen Winstead? Why Is She Taking Revenge This Way?

Carmen Winstead is a name that appears in spooky chain letters that have circulated online in various forms, all telling the same story with the same consequences. One such chain letter reads as follows:

Advertisement

"Hi, my name is Carmen Winstead. I'm 17 years old. I am very similar to you… Did I mention to you that I'm dead? A few years ago a group of girls pushed me down a sewer hole to try and embarrass me. When I didn't come back up the police came. The girls said that I had fell and everyone believed them. The police found my body in the sewer. I had a broken neck and my face was torn off. Send this message to 15 people after you read the whole message if you value your life! A boy called David received this message. He just laughed and deleted it. When he was in the shower he heard laughing… MY LAUGHTER! He got really scared, rushed to his phone to repost this message… But he was too late. The next morning his mum entered his bedroom and all she found was a message written in his blood saying, "You will never have him back!" No one has found his body yet… because he is with me!… Send this to 15 people in the next 5 minutes if you don't want your fate to be the same as David's. Your time starts… NOW! The story is true you can research it on google"

Advertisement

There Are Some Other Versions Too

"She was pushed!" Approximately 6 years ago in Indiana, Carmen Winstead was pushed down a sewer opening by 5 girls at her school during a fire drill, in an attempt to embarrass her. When she did not emerge, the police were called. They retrieved 17-year-old Carmen's body, which had a broken neck from hitting the ladder and the concrete at the bottom of the sewer. The girls claimed that Carmen had fallen, and their story was believed. Two months ago, 16-year-old David Gregory read this story and did not repost it. While taking a shower, he heard laughter coming from the shower and became panicked. He ran to his computer to repost the message. He said goodnight to his mom and went to sleep, but 5 hours later, his mom woke up to a loud noise and discovered that David was gone. The police found his body in the sewer the next morning, with a broken neck and his face skin peeled off. If you do not repost this message saying "She was pushed!" or "They pushed her down the sewer!", Carmen will come after you through the sewer, toilet, shower, or when you are asleep. You will wake up in the sewer, in the dark, and Carmen will come to kill you.

Advertisement

or,

"She was pushed!" Approximately 6 years ago in Indiana, Jessica Smith was pushed down a sewer opening by 5 girls at her school during a fire drill, in an attempt to embarrass her. When she did not emerge, the police were called. They retrieved 17-year-old Jessica's body, which had a broken neck from hitting the ladder and the concrete at the bottom of the sewer. The girls claimed that Jessica had fallen, and their story was believed. Two months ago, 16-year-old Ron Anderson read this story and did not repost it. While taking a shower, he heard laughter coming from the shower and became panicked. He ran to his computer to repost the message. He said goodnight to his mom and went to sleep, but 5 hours later, his mom woke up to a loud noise and discovered that Ron was gone. The police found his body in the sewer the next morning, with a broken neck and his face skin peeled off. If you do not repost this message saying "She was pushed!" or "They pushed her down the sewer!", Jessica will come after you through the sewer, toilet, shower, or when you are asleep. You will wake up in the sewer, in the dark, and Jessica will come to kill you.

Advertisement

It is evident that the chain letters are urging readers to share the words in order to avoid a cruel end at the hands of the deceased Carmen (or Jessica).

Is There Any Truth Behind The Story Of Carmen Winstead?

It is not true that a teenage girl named Carmen Winstead or Jessica Smith died in this way, in Indiana or any other state in the United States, about six years ago (2000). If such a tragedy had occurred, it would have been reported in the news. However, upon searching for news reports, no such story can be found. This tale is simply a work of fiction, a common chain letter often favored by pre-teens.

Advertisement

Chain letters often consist of stories designed to generate luck or avoid bad luck, and are meant to persuade recipients to share them with others through mail or social networking sites like Facebook, Whatsapp, or MySpace. Some well-known chain letters include "Bloody Mary," "Teddy," "Clarissa," and others.

Conclusion

The story of Carmen Winstead is generally considered an "urban legend," with widespread popularity among internet users. However, some believe that the absence of proof does not necessarily mean the incident never occurred. They suggest that it may have happened in another part of the world, with the details modified to appeal to a new audience. Currently, the tale of Carmen Winstead has gained popularity outside the United States, with numerous searches for information originating from the Philippines.

Advertisement